Labor opened the door to One Nation: “Imitation always loses to the original”
Labor’s failure is that it accepts One Nation’s frame, then pretends to oppose One Nation’s consequences. It feeds the politics of fear and division, expands punitive laws, postures on borders and security, then condemns the monster when it grows. Labor has become One Nation’s rehearsal act. It borrows the language, softens it for certain audiences, and leaves One Nation to collect the votes.
The imitation always loses to the original
Labor and the Liberals keep trying to outflank the far right by sounding tougher on immigration, security and national identity. But voters who want that politics will eventually choose the party that speaks it without embarrassment. Once politics becomes a competition over who can sound most hostile, multicultural and minority communities are the first to pay the price.
Tony Burke as the test case
Tony Burke postures as tough on borders and security. He cancels visas when it suits his political survival, even where due process, proportionality and consistency become secondary to political optics. The Liberals then posture even harder. One Nation simply goes further. That is the trap. Labor thinks it can neutralise the far right by borrowing its vocabulary. In reality, it validates the terrain on which the far right wins.
Labor wants votes without our dignity
Labor wants Muslim and migrant votes in Western Sydney, but refuses to defend Muslim and migrant dignity when the media, the Liberals or the far right come hunting. It wants loyalty without consequence. It wants communities to keep voting Labor while Labor keeps treating their concerns as politically inconvenient.
Cowardice should not be rewarded
Labor learned from the last Federal Election that it can abandon Muslims and still receive Muslim votes, and why should that change when it has never faced the backlash it needs to shift it by votes? Political loyalty without consequences is not loyalty; it is permission to maintain such behaviour and still expect loyalty.
The Farrer warning
The Farrer by-election is not just a Coalition problem; it is a warning. One Nation’s victory shows what happens when resentment is organised and political cowardice is rewarded. The far right does not grow in a vacuum. It grows when major parties validate its fears, adopt its language and then act surprised when voters choose the party that says it more bluntly.
One Nation wants Western Sydney and Labor is not the answer
One Nation is not walking toward Western Sydney alone. Labor and the Liberals opened the door by turning migrants, Muslims and multicultural communities into political instruments whenever it suited them. If One Nation now believes it can campaign in the heart of multicultural Australia, it is because the major parties have spent years making suspicion of these communities politically usable.
The community lesson
The lesson from Farrer is not fear; it is discipline. Communities that organise can change political outcomes. Communities that vote without demands are taken for granted. The answer to divisive politics is not retreat, silence or reactionary politics of our own. It is disciplined political organisation grounded in principle, consistency and accountability.
Labor’s strategy is obvious. It does not believe it needs to change policy, principle or protection to retain Muslim and migrant votes. It believes these communities will complain, absorb the insult, and return home on election day. That is why its language barely shifts. When Muslims are attacked, Labor speaks with qualifiers. When Palestinians are killed, Labor begins with Israel’s right to defend itself before reducing Palestinian suffering to a passing afterthought. When our communities are targeted, Labor reaches for unity language instead of political courage. It is asking for loyalty while proving that loyalty has earned us almost nothing.
Things to remember
Labor will not change its policy, principle or protection to win Muslim or migrant votes. But it is asking for loyalty without having to meaningfully shift the bar.
Labor asks for loyalty on the strong belief that communities will never change. Because it assumes these communities will never politically realign, never impose consequences and never withdraw support.
Political parties do not change through moral appeals alone. They change when votes move.
The answer to divisive politics is not retreat, silence or reactionary politics of our own. It is disciplined political organisation grounded in principle, consistency and accountability.
What must happen now?
Join local organising efforts now. Sign up, volunteer, door-knock, attend forums, bring family members into the conversation, and make sure every household understands the stakes before 2028 (links below). Politics changes when communities stop whispering and start moving together.
Follow us on Instagram
